Music.
Welcome to the Bredow Cast this is a podcast of the Leibniz-Institut
for media research in Hamburg Germany my name is Johanna sebauer and in this podcast iam talking to media research is about the
working today in this episodes were discussing something rather groundbreaking I would say the Social-Media-Plattform Facebook.
We are now it has for the first time in history laut.
Research as access to the Headquarters to investigate in an embedded fashion.
The platform from within and the resurgence of our institute were the first to study for Facebook develops rules that shaped two point seven billion people communicate.
Pizzeria dolce the hill today Wolfgang Schulz and Matthias kettemann Facebook coming,
Hallo Becky bring heaven is very quickly into you thank you and I will jump right into the topic Wolfgang Schulz the one the directors of the Leibniz-Institut von Media Research die Ausfahrt eaches medialer University of Hamburg and is
bezahlt died aussois director at the Humboldt Institut für Internet and society in Berlin.
Matthias kettemann ist Ace Inge research ahirette Leibniz-Institut für Media Research he is the speaker of a research program that focuses on how
rules and the new practices of communication Developing digital,
es fehlt and here is currently also a guest professor at the University of Heidelberg teaching international law.
Best Practice correct one of Justice Meta information we all German speakers but we decided since this topic is quite international to speak English to Oslo.
Maeckes Podcast more accessible for people that don't speak German the well.
Okay so let's jump right into the topic that of you were able to investigate to the research Facebook from within.
Research is facebook has been sold of a black box I would say for Far Cry the wild YouTube the research about auf Facebook influences how people communicate Highways
Influenza the News consumption offiziersassistent Reset robot way to look inside and and see how this company works from within HNA
askew Wolfgang know how did this whole project come about how did you gain access to the company.
Song the starting point is that thing for a couple of years we are studying the
estructuras Norbert estructuras of public communication and the song is that the tethering what companies like Facebook and others do with the code of conduct aller der Standard has become more and more important,
Influnce Papi communication and secondly we have very often in conferences we need more information about how the rules come about Arber constructed
what are the procedures in which they am construit en son and people always said it's impossible you cannot login to it you needn't
ASG because it's for sure that you won't get access a voi.
Seychellen Chicks up that we will try and sorry started Konversation Wallpaper from face
Rocker MC think we were lucky because after the Cambridge analytica scandal the walls and debate wird in Facebook
what does that mean for us to dream now be completely closed for academic research or should we even be more open and ever more structured Texas to internal information
abfängt building on that we were able to convince them.
Them to give as access the level that has not been granted before YouTube Facebook.
Was ist Mark Zuckerberg entschlossen break with you work work work this year but I was not about this project main point of entry is.
Expert jatt Facebook Kurs coordinating the Stakeholder groups Academy is one of the important Stakeholder groups
ähm sorry is the first point of contact und was extremely helpful in organizing how to get access to the.
Ddlme Walking groups are we wanted to study.
TOGGO WM 66 mampfer.
Eben made to be frank and understand that,
because it's the first time I have to develop the the rules have to convince a lot of
people internally and the lawyers always Aaron obstacle run away because I'm a liar bei education.com dakovo.
So you were sold of negotiating for six months and what what did you agree upon in the end.
Sorry our agreement is that we can have could have access to
all the relevant Walking Group Meetings that take place in the process from
the first sick note that the Community Standards Facebook might be changed Anteil der Fahnder Decision-Making swisschange sorry we could have access to the order steps from this first
indischer Ford about changing the rules to actually changing the more deciding that they should not be
changed the ties
Nazi died in a paper that is very complex process within the company of the law of people outside the company play a key role and have access to all the different settings Whiskey for research Rente,
weniger Ski hätte Tattoo year we can come after Sex as mentioned is now.
Partnerstädte preprint in the Republic later into the wind twenty NLP Review German we will of course link to this in the Show notes,
so that the goal of your project was to find out how Facebook develops rules,
voll Kommunikationsnetz Plattform Matthias when you went over there,
you went to California to spend some time at Facebook Headquarters.
What's your impression what did you do today what was your day we live
schlüsselliste erprobt wird we will only able to do this project Pegasus
the level of trust you have been building
Ende research startet Wolfgang system has been collecting oder was die Yuuzhan on how complication changes in ha,
the rules of life the actress influenced the way we communicate außerdem public Settings very happy after a long discussions with colleagues from other disciplines
to table to conduct a first-hand research where to talk to participants.
Affe Serie The Walking groups have to imagine haben Komplex normativ change happens.
Wir the product policies William Bruce of form of communication within Facebook.
Beinahe an intricate oder that is constantly evolving and changing when there is even the codesignal so finster.
Koblenz in application of certain rules or am.
Research and south of my way to decisions on the side terrace with the shit with me to be dealt with them.
Bester time working group on Saturday for them talk about the youth and the possible.
Changes that policies can can can argentavis start consulting with stakeholders and Stakeholder processing.
Am Morgen wir Remus Interesting parts of the soul policy change because they identify,
who they want to talk to which they can impact the air.
The poor Paraparese change process not able to attend this this meetings and listening to the course of incredible Interesting haben wir Jeffrey deswegen vor den Türmen.
Interpres idealizing the return to train to get more knowledge that outcome.
Christoph kursnet.de facebook ist nervös national legislation and the advantage of the state.
Wetter Herbst sollten in Finn Sekret Stimme See in setting rules governing how we communicate.
Selenit find the way to to increase data to Timothy in der Gegenwart bei.
Bei Vanessa vorm the mountains and the attempt to indicate the opinions of the different stakeholders.
Pharmaton beverages Dinger Avia captor expensive notes.
The base on the search within developed a cappella furious an Hardturm.
Ja Facebook Germany Facebook structures innovativ change.
Could you give us an example of concrete Rot-Weiß-Rot-Karte locquirec.
Absolutely so one of the new product policy.
Skylines avussilber aufstehen leitet to the question how people.
The change the general entity altried IT-Service might seem like a niche Problem Mädel
Odyssey damage touches upon the human dignity of people within the floor to have changed their identity,
what Facebook-Server dermaviduals Avastin in certain circles.
Bis people who have changed your identity were attacked by Frances Bean called.
Ey General Brunnen fernandinho identified with.
The prince and the woman who had the changes Gentleman would be referred to by the old channel planner.
And and Facebook the number of rows of meeting with experts and try to find out,
Frau sagte des Horns people who changed their identity and how they can,
developing new rules of circumstances.
Using the round in the burning wood Beben Ration of the rhythm the guidelines.
Office leben bis es in is you where you have,
no global norms jetzt Werneuchen Reitstall scrollytelling a company or is data to act in in this example bis goodbye,
one of those cases were called to have to consider carefully hardway freedom of expression and human dignity
hab's auch Sylt Breschnew privacy and facebook ist in Teesieb agincourt switch to the rats in the process of the team norms.
The devil privatizing in a certain way only The Legend of Aang the way of the judicial function.
1. Trimenon Center moraitis oder den vorstehenden Ohren.
Which makes the mercy widowmaker in the name of the disco soletek weather today Show actual,
rauchst du denn Nomen vorschulbücher Sehtest.
Beim Abspielen der Terraner competence to the just you and for the decision by veräppelt the spending somebody.
Zu der Aprilia Mana Preise Badeparadies Paul.
This is why it's important to enter into this discussion and open up the forces of autonom selbst überrascht.
So happy today were able to contribute Facebook.
Absolutely your favorite extreme Interesting to look at this companies more generally,
UFO gesehen in Facebook Bürkel railroad to gain access the rabbit facebook is by no means the only a company Setting setting for the rules.
Ende des ARGE play even if anything criticize the slow speed of NAV binding Update central alarm.
Decision-making process is much much for the world to the cart ability than other companies that the.
Word we were we were soldiers have to rely on on the XML file at bitte bei Darmoperation practices.
Wird auch so easy Thüringer tötete criticize batteriestraße.
Bist du aus Halsey one with important that the company took this step Chinchillas.
Und jede Seite facebook ist notieren ich komponiere Sets privat rules why is Facebook 3-Sitzer important that we look at Facebook eure Gewinne.
Too much importance maybe also research institute,
Arbeitszeiten in general aber Instituts Perspektive is not to look at one type of medium and within,
Pacific times of Media not just one company of one specific service and I think that is that this
gute Prozent in public debate sometimes the role of social media platforms and especially facebook.at Philipp overstated we just look at the new phenomenon and neglect the best of the things around the traditional media player roll
facebook is extremely important player in this respect and we might learn something which is Interesting
study with other companies Auswahl einfach
parrot.com ever different styles of the good practices merge links RTL thinking about what.
Should be the normative order of public communication how can we ensure that the the fundamentals freedoms are guaranteed in the
Innere System where we have fun and very complex interplay between states that rules and rule set by companies that one of a main research interest for the next year is in this is a very important cornerstone trouble with research,
er ist mit likelikelike Jane Goodall an harris Arjan und beagate singer.
Augustusburg Skifahren rbb.de Nummer TV oder AV fenati transfers to Arkhan the fifth of monkeyspot.
Osteria important example of how the scandal Werner Mauss Intrac.
Heroes of Latina comparing eine company töte MSN im Facebook Herr serwery
KV Position also treated by by politiko actress including the EU including Performance exemplary object or regulations
it's it's very much 10.SSW bitte auf auf auf Acer one media company.
Amna Facebook hate.
Chordify United of headlines recently we think of Cambridge analytica friend.
It's not so far fetched to thank you facebook app I doing this opening up to
Research s.to The Voice Match entsperren and maybe your soul Whitewash rabbit what do you think of this.
Satin definitely true that they want to show the bear transparent but I think that's not the problem if they are in fact transparent and open up like that song.
Erfinder Dieselmotor versenken aber Motor vorbei
brannte das access is that it is interesting for them to learn about and procedures for men outsiders perspective so der Hefte uninteressant everybody has where to have our research interest they have
never Interesting don't think that we went gaijin.net whitewashing here because we just.
The Pact what we have observed and what is important to us for this research two things one is that it is embedded in,
theoretical framework within develope
Zimmer für dolle Joey and das not just opportunistically seeing all that something happening here and jumping on that that I think extremely important when you do discount of research to make sure that this.
Actually the academic research that serves the academic community.
Dad is important in the second thing is that we wanted to make sure that the path from access we don't get any
sing vom Facebook-Server there was no funding of anything I paid for a flight for accommodation
things like that to make sure we just want them to open up and everything else is a business.
And good Facebook indie and influence the findings that you got the content of the people that will be published.
Now what we agreed time and we talk about that I love because that is something that
they are allowed to review the paper but just for two things one is privacy issues on the other thing is trade secrets and,
that is not request anything on on the spaces are the paper that we will publish is not influenced by anything that that face
Buxheim bei der Fink we have to make transparent data have been this process es wird hell
bin just Interviews everyone have agreed to this kind of Procedure because when you say that you say that in the end we have to do that but when you are embedded value see everything and I can
look at things that have to do with personal data of users or personal of faith
Brücke all you could accidently ilockit of something which is something that is in development and has not been announced so fremd so um
the entry Grid on on this procedure without end of pioneering work and we welcome the discussion about what is the proper method when you.
Du das Kaindorf of embedded research alarm sectors of academia more experience perfect for us is relatively new attitude that some
Nordirland EM,
pioneering in terms of of research questions but also in terms of how to engage with this kind of Magic company that is in the public debate everyday
Endingen to dance on the radio Leibniz-Institut für Media Research we we truly find that.
You get the best results scientifically the combine interdisciplinary have a strong focus on on regulation on on on the searching registrations browser on doing there are based on,
an empirical evidence to combine media studies and religious studies and the debate in this project is well with.
ROC search the paper at least is dedicated exclusively to a methodological approach the weekly Layout.
How we come to the conclusion.
Udo Witte oder der dampfmeister wakin replicata ihr Stadion the harvest honors the Avatar methods,
eine kleine Tabata results in the very happy together.
Werbeseite Fäkalien Swissair very confident in in ironsight progress we were aware.
Das sind this is this is the use of the pioneering study and the case study of one company NL Franco campanino Dartboard.
Service based on one company that not always will be generalizable.
Batam in the run-up to the project in run-up to the embedded face.
Perdix Dance FM transportations with colleagues from Mars NASA James archeology 50 a lot of media.
From media studies morgen Oli Turnschuhe Dart.
April Chase family Eintritt in in in Köln scientific Methodological discourse you
basically Doing crossing field studies in Facebook.
Bei es ist in eure observing meetings of the team dead,
critrolestats solvent in ethnographic research we can say.
Über die talk to the people with the brave General chocolat
background-color erst nach Internet ist Nagelfee Pickel kann sodass der usually is Kassel embedded faces
could have to take longer to be really to be real with embedded within the period of three to six months at least.
Erlanger Jude for one week we are the spirits.
Also One Line one source update BIOS arrilite heavily on.
On an online course which we are organized with the participants to be aware that the teams with working on specific changes are based in ten to twenty different locations.
Zeitwunder von eine Differenz to discourse based on California.
Und jedem hier vom Hamburger you talk to people from London von Sydney from von Afrika.
And that's the way that normativ policy changes happens there is a river in the way that is awaiting the same without a Facebook employees for participating in the disco.
So deswegen Physik www.isny.de Start not the end of our offer data collection.
Letzte Tage Land mit Moorbad yo-kai mit facebook you were there I say to you.
Everyday the US is that Meetings Radio 4 how did I think they treated you the researcher do you think they acted in a different way that you were there.
One call away Service presented at the researcher and Daniel at the other two to observe the butt.
From what I can't hear the role extremely give the actress of Ages the day that it is discussed what they want to discuss any way that they have something to hide address nervig conspiracy at work.
Wer team of people trying to develope.
Policies that sometimes implicated difficult choices die verkohlte Wedding auf.
What values are more important than ever speaking ten NCT
the silent voice they call it the day I looking for freedom of expression sometimes the situations where.
Und könnte sein da da da kannst du Ration Situation you the privacy Europe rapsta.
Human human rights related to the development of self actualization represented in the discourse Buddies Adresse innerhalb.
Alternator ist Fehling error that anybody was praying to the audience,
aber der ist auch Sky one of many participants in this meeting suck at the very low profile
funny people weather in this role making them what is it called officially policy the city of Heroes
THE DEAD one of the times looking at the rules the related to memory usage communication Rossetti Imst related to Developing Warsaw nananana zu den verkehrsarzt.
Gib depending on the colours Meeting you have oder the one to one meeting with the wedding date with the specific and your business frenssens
error error remix bad Meetings where are the between five and ten people
where you'd get report from different parts of the organisation although I have a feeling about this meaning.
How do you say gorgeous in Afrika viewer a possible change address specific use we would have to be aware of the.
Gerade eine cultural Katrin zentristisch ist das wird ihm Lied in den Palazzo might not be,
spiel mir das Lied where does Holly have local businesses that write to channel local civil society.
Zu der train virtual reality.
Wow in Marzahn koliba you came came the way you feeling the really trying to developers and the Bastards.
Ein Wort keines Pippo ein des Teams all diesen Lego Skales oder.
Sergio Generali successful intelligent Django academics between wurden academic background.
Doing abc twenty five to two three four forty some exceptions to the survey with the number of participants.
Der gestiefelte Kater die Nummer citysafe Offenheit ready impressive track record.
Parfums Edith before coming to the team.
Am korstick Geitz in the way the frames in their thinking this is not making a Facebook different from any other successful.
Social media company or Oreo any any any company I will get the people who.
Driving with the best company for what you got to know that you have very similar Make-ups.
Eine zurzeit think it's not dominated by low er sowieso erst den gesamten contact partners in pieces Tory und neu.
By education was a lot of experience in other countries and other field sum sum with multiple values in my career.
Rider strong a feeling of a family atypical Diplomatie
Hefei specific specialization of news and defence Settings von want you to next and you would have a talk to you Tab
teams of a place of birth of the scientist suffocation scientist and the Furious Autos mit walking on different areas which Tamtam strange inerten of reviewers develop their there is no.
The snow high high level of specialization.
Mit Wasser des gerade sense of community the sense of working together on trying to find a good solution for lack of a better world.
Maybe we can discuss.
One example of how a certain row comes about me about me when we can take the example the gender identity is you that you mentioned earlier this this issue.
Reis.
Er wird in Facebook ersetzt something people from outside take too faced when say I am well you this can you please do something about it be presented in the EU.
Guys minitüb setaro scrolling we ändern Hause den Prozess
what what is the process of making the making them what the fuck is a different one the one recording.
Pro pro white hate speech nam3 call at the year to Christchurch rather quickly Facebook
come into I will let sollten keinen the VVV white national ist hate speech should be could be taking down and
glaube mir da was ist das fehlende grau Recycling Action chillisimo event.
Barsbüttel sagst wenn ihr wenn ihr panda.upb.de tonight.de have been working on a new Street Triple SIM.
Reinigung Weidner schon sinnvoll verkreuzen time what would happen here Schule ist ja gut geht aus Singles people say we look at this is you can turn into days.
Silke reality is the the the the the the national this is not a problem Online-Office lay of the the the the crossing across the world
visit people from outside leg and geology Rosewood wood would be one of the singles the community.
Empress of the proposal Team good look at the scars of content reflect return without content that other users CS trouble in.
David central Sports through the use of the chain.
David and up with www.vol.at Team NFL Reporter Team Feldbett.
Der wo sind deine Amerikaner für Preisschild tututu Store changing ist sollten policy Woodstock desbrosses auf.
Auf developing auf Giraffe Försterin defying wie ich hier seit Hand wenn wir den gay Twitter Nintendo.
Den Turner science team of the look at the airport the end of the scientists believe it starts playing with stakeholders wingate Schilf.
Booty calls to make up the wood brothers of the tin number of working group sessions and onesafe
Berta der Herd reach the good the good proposal David bring that today am product policy Forum Buddy the Buddy Parlament if you will
Werbepräsente der.
Taylor Haven Energie a nice PowerPoint presentation for Africa policy change the patients or online.
Beinahe soll der jetzt auf dem Tab the product policy Forum Germany Parlament Ikea Bielefeld eimler gegen Vollautomat online Office PowerPoint.
Seine Fertigkeiten und video where can you find the view dürfte lugato Mörtel Facebook-Server Website Dante.
Just as a German product policy formula.
Wie groß ist es von contended Form Video aufnehmen.
Inventer you take decision under the room would be the way you move
necessarily the the rooms temperature with the gates in in in in in a computer science this this is you this is the concept of rough consensys.
Ich bin aus Napoli strong reposted than you know this is part of that accepted and implemented.
How often do I can really spiderman yesterday evening every other week I decided upon the three to five.
Darlehen Jobcenter activities to review.
Ende ist Mark Zuckerberg aus der Teilung des Team Sontheim Service Parlament Roboter des meetings raus product policy for a farm okay.
Thank you what you said and I got the impression that
Miss Miss Handwerk sometimes it ends by the way I do the better I wanna have you mean that the leadership is not involved
Indianer proces istina sometimes the singles to change rooms come from leadership.
Bickert impression that lagerfeuerlieder,
admicash and processes are taking place of behind the scenes with some simple steps to leadership first reaction on how
oder halife wieder da erinnere Motiv change the world depending on whether this change is happening.
Case Lolly come to an end of this Episode I would I would ask you to maybe.
Summarise in in in in Viersen is what the what is the Mentalist pilots story.
Verheiraten
Lotto Take-Aways you have we have to be more is there because it's just the case study there is something that we cannot see for example people and we would be interested in
aber Intervention inter des Browsers for academic purposes
we have no ziehen.in Auerochse Bayerischen Backzeit
obviously does not mean that it does not exist but coming to do things that we possibly have learned er ist what we can see here is a separate rulemaking
process in which references the other no matter Frameworks like state law international law is not
Bury prominent notfallplätze but nevertheless the process to some extent Simulator law-making procedures wie groß war der try to do is to identify the interest at stake and her to find the balance well that is what we can see when I look at you.
The national state law making and the second thing that was striking for a sister
importance of the external Stakeholder representatives partly academics partly representatives of interest groups
that in the internal conversation Willi
play major role Matthias pointed out that it is an argument to know what Africa Song what this interest groups are the weather summer academics Arm.
Okay wo fährt fährt have experience in,
ey Human Rights freedom of speech the discourse of things like that server.pro the two things we we found extremely interesting and which of the bases of a future studies.
Ja aber telegram Nordirland deshalb korrekt bei denen Inmarsat Programm original lernen Wolfgang Sartorius with
RMB deep space is where there is important for.
For erinner wollte signing up on the future of the Republic and and and the public what happens with the rest of the private.
Am End.
This means that the character of the rules that impact lost spaces arabische Wort privates well.
The Weeknd just stop the research with other citizens of the world we have to ask ourselves with the inquiry Ali in Haarfabrik in Meschede privat rules against,
Heia Heia Schweizer Base Standard.
Du bist 17 in this project that the facebook is doing that there are trying to.
Slowly trying to to to to push the apartments into contact context with with international commitments and the room
direction the shaking is this the new oversight Board.
Which were the giant Hilden am too old international oversight of the content decisions with your Sideboard Wings ansible for certain specific Hard Case S-Line
process überwinden Schlüsselgewalt manual focus on TUM Props to the last thing I wanted to mention in Inneres Krismer Facebook where is this this feeling bad.
Visual product Facebook.
Ist Richard Henschen bitte serie the selling of attention to derivatization I zuverlässig of using we will we are Facebook support,
www.techdata.de you can that way way way without more sophisticated words with the just reading of that
the call that the the path of the company that is dedicated Developing roses call the product policy Team Wii.
Verdster Chilis.
Perücke sailor Facebooks product is the securities space and the rules.
Plattform das BMW Touring jacket reinventing the things are just at the ready important or inside
Dacia Lodgy conditions auf meiner today's kommunikativ moderne TWW interlink geht Spielfilm Freiwild spaces and the rose.
AAA something we have focus on the love to you not to to to to to the jungle Cruise forever forever ever fight company stream.
Aminatou Defekt Verlauf auf der anderen the role in the jar accountability will much Bionda.
Discord offline countability is never enough we need to be firm about the rules.
Alice company developed and we have to be able to qualify them in terms of their impact on public communication.
Project with the first step to voltage Rangliste database Vorwort.
Looking into the future will there be more research institute on this subject and if so what will be its focus.
For eternity Volbeat the aspect of private ordering in
Papi communication is something that you want to visit around the next couple of years the song one thing is taking igen facebook is an example that
the sensation of the other side Board double cr-1020.
Change the process that we have observed
envia in field value writing to what extent,
actually changes and I think even the evil within Facebook the design this this concept and and implemented at
cannot really fancy what that actually means because one of you is the other side Board is about individual cases
inside us not really influence the policy making the role making but when you have the leading cases on the specific is you then
and this this is not empty surfing on conflict that is the packable tool to many conflicts of the torch on the platform then that creates a rule
Sarah Dikanda blies Seperator you while making from the other side Board work and what that actually means for this procedures as I think open end.
It very much
pants on the framework for the oversight Board and the commitment of the people on the other side Board weathervane just surface book in
Battlerap lying down Standard Zweihand privat rules over there they see themselves as Guardians of human rights is bringing the side his perspective into that and when they do that then we will then have a kind of hybrids normativsystem the the this party privat-und partly mom from constructed from from the public societal
Wii U and that is extremely interesting to study and work some very fundamental questions about how we
SETI normativ order of the STS Digitized public spaces.
The green and the Stooges Stegmann Notfall example.
Internet Textilpflege Rossmann Facebook get deleted this Econic.
Pictures of me chords of a fan of Phan thi Kim Phuc the girl playing from the Napalm,
baumbänke Rumble the the the pictures of course they are united Charles something that any algorithm botfly immediately,
ride for dessert and deleted high for this with Chinese in Headshops in the ship bye bye face.
Love Rosie auf denen gewartet kannst du das ziemlich episch Lied Sabine steht still wird.
Hättest du sie selber leitet Facebook weißt du denn was du Dustin re restore the image.
We believe that the processing wolfgangsee.at describe the lead to point work with Position seiner taking the vacuum based on on on the fire TV.
For fire UPS in the company based on Hey increasingly.
Dance normativ Argentino mit Defense normativ Bergland,
simple put more rules.
Erste Seite im Small more rain jacket we give them or US Facebook DIWA Website gibt es Moro and it Trex Tim bergling Kieselerde timothée to the Globus take the community
das haben die Moves Hinterausgang described adwoa Sideboard mein impact the process engine and Lena not saying that in the lower Browser the citizen,
having more rules that hold the last weekend is always a good thing.
Bänke Matthias
Thank You Wolfgang for this insights into your study anyone listening to this podcast require more information über Feinde
Link für das Darlehen schon aus als wäre es eventuell website and Twitter account if you wish to first things first thing in the nighttime dann Gewehr much thank you.
Music.